Preparing for and Explaining in Discussions

Question 1

Your class is talking about why recycling is important. Yesterday you read the article "Why Recycling Helps the Earth" and wrote three notes: (1) recycling reduces trash in landfills, (2) it saves energy, and (3) it protects wildlife. During the discussion, which of the following statements shows you correctly using your notes to support your point?

Accepted Answer

The article said that recycling reduces the amount of trash that ends up in landfills, so I believe that's one big reason to recycle.

Answer

I think recycling is good because it helps the planet.

Answer

My friend said recycling is cool, so we should do it.

Answer

Recycling is important, and we should all do it every day.

Question 2

During a group discussion about the main idea of a story, Maya says, "I think the main idea is about friendship because the characters help each other." Which of the following responses best shows how a student should engage effectively in the discussion?

Accepted Answer

I agree with Maya and add that the friendship is shown when the characters share their toys, which also supports the main idea.

Answer

That's a good point, but let's move on to the next question.

Answer

Can you repeat what you said? I didn't understand.

Answer

I think my idea is better; the main idea is about adventure, not friendship.

Question 3

During a group discussion about the main idea of a story, which of the following statements best shows a student engaging effectively in the discussion?

Accepted Answer

I think the main idea is about helping friends, and I noticed that when the character shared her snack, she helped her friend feel better, which supports that idea.

Answer

I don't think anyone's ideas are right, so we should just stop talking about the story.

Answer

I'm not sure what the main idea is, so I will stay quiet and let others decide.

Answer

I have a lot of ideas, so I will keep talking while the others listen.

Try three questions

During a group discussion about the main idea of a story, Maya says, "I think the main idea is about friendship because the characters help each other." Which of the following responses best shows how a student should engage effectively in the discussion?

During a group discussion about the main idea of a story, which of the following statements best shows a student engaging effectively in the discussion?

Keep going on this shelf